Saturday, November 10, 2012

Books For Sale

Hey, readers! Please note that my new book Going Home is now available on the sidebar of the blog, under the 'Stuff By Me You Can Buy' heading. It's a great little book that will only set you back $20.00 or so, and give you lots to ponder on the power of God's mercy in our lives. Buy it, y'all!
And don't forget my other products (while I'm shamelessly floggin my wares), She is Our Response, The Air We Breathe, and my set of CDs, The Fundamentals of the Spiritual Life, all of which are eminently purchaseable and chock full of essential vitamins and minerals. Buy them now, before they become collector's items!

Goodness Without God?

The question is whether we accept reality as pure matter or as the expression of a meaning that refers to us; whether we invent values or must find them. On our answer depends the kind of freedom of which we must speak, for two completely different freedoms, two completely different fundamental attitudes toward life, are involved here.
Principles of Catholic Theology, 72

Reflection – This is a very penetrating and simply put expression of the fundamental modern controversy. Do we invent reality, or is reality a given? Do we invent the moral law, or do we discover it? Is freedom to be the exercise of our wholly autonomous self-will imposing our ego upon a dead universe, or is freedom something more like a quest, an adventure, a bold setting out into an already existing meaning and truth?
It seems to me that it is one or the other. The truth is out there, or there is no truth except what we impose by our own strength. We have to be as clear about this as we can be in our minds. And it does come down to the question of God. If there is no God, how can there be a pre-existing moral law? Law must come from a law-giver.

When we speak of the laws of nature, we are using the word analogically; we simply mean that physical objects do the same sorts of things in the same sorts of conditions in a predictable fashion that we can utilize for technological advancement. There are no ‘laws’ of nature in the sense that there are laws of human conduct. If there is a true moral law, there is a true moral Lawgiver.

People will argue that you can be good without God, that lots of irreligious people manage to live good moral lives. It would be a fool’s game to dispute that. I would say though, that without God the word goodness becomes emptied of meaning. If there is no God, what is this goodness of which you speak?

Where does it come from? What is its rational basis? It really is true that without God all things are permitted. Civil society may choose to punish certain behaviors that violate the social order, but that cannot be the basis of what we mean by ‘good’ and ‘bad’ behavior. Do we really want to concede to the State the power to define morality?

Nor can it be morality by social consensus—like we all agree that adulterers are vile or something. Social consensus changes, and there are always minority opinions about virtually anything. Pedophilia has it defenders even now, as does incest, as does bestiality. Lots of people think it is just fine to lie and steal. We cannot have a rational moral theory based on social consensus, and it is against common sense to base it on civil and criminal law.

What else is left? Without a God who is the fashioner of reality and its ultimate adjudicator, there is no such thing as a moral law. And if there is no such thing as a moral law, then all things are permitted. And if all things are permitted, the ruthless and the powerful will continue to have their way with the rest of us. God and God alone provides a way out from this quandary.

Of course some will argue that this delivers us over to an even more debasing slavery to an even more ruthless and powerful being, except this time it is for all eternity and there’s no escape. This is why we cannot live a theistic life without a sense of God’s mercy and tender love. If this all-powerful all-good God who does indeed impose upon us the demnads of the moral law is not also all-merciful and all-compassionate, then we are indeed in a pickle. But He is, and so we are not so tragic. We are OK, really.

More than OK, we are free, then, to embark on the high adventure of reality, of good and evil, and to prevail with God’s help in the epic of life and its glorious challenge.

Friday, November 9, 2012

An Assured Strength, A Virile Tenderness

Contemporary men and women have difficulty experiencing the great consolation of the word father immediately, since the experience of father is in many cases either completely absent or is obscured by inadequate examples of fatherhood.

We must therefore let Jesus teach us what father really means. In Jesus’ discourses, the Father appears as the source of all good, as the measure of the rectitude (perfection) of man. ‘But I say to you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be sons of your Father who is in heaven…’ (Mat 5:44). The love that endures to the end (Jn 13:1), which the Lord fulfilled on the Cross in praying for his enemies, shows us the essence of the Father. He is this love. Because Jesus brings it to completion, he is entirely ‘Son’, and he invites us to become ‘sons’ according to this criterion.
Jesus of Nazareth 1, 136

Reflection – Well, this is a subject dear to my heart. In fact, I’ve just written a book about it, Going Home, which explores the nature of God the Father and his infinite tenderness and love from the perspective of the parable of the Prodigal Son. When we find out just who and what this ‘Father’ is, at least a little bit, so many things fall into place, become much easier, make so much more sense. When we have very little or no sense of the Father’s love, Christian faith and indeed life in general is a dark heavy sad thing.

I know this, actually, because I have been one of those contemporary men for whom the word father held little consolation. Without going into a big personal testimony that would be inappropriate in this public setting, I did not have the best of relationships with my own father, and consequently the word for me was not associated with very positive associations.

It was Jesus who showed me the true face of fatherhood. Specifically, he told me that he did nothing that he did not see his Father in heaven doing (John 5:19). So everything Jesus does in the Gospels reveals to us the Father’s heart. Healing the sick, raising the dead, casting out demons, feeding the hungry, forgiving sinners, teaching, proclaiming, and loving to the very end of love—all of this is who God the Father is and what He does continually. Even Jesus’ death on the Cross is ‘what he sees his Father doing’. God the Father does not suffer and die on the Cross with Jesus—that is a heresy that has been long condemned. But Jesus’ death is a revelation that there is no limit, no boundaries to God’s love, to what the Father wills to do to save his errant children. Love poured out to the last drop of love—but because God is infinite, there is no last drop. Love poured out eternally, perfectly, utterly, right now, on you, on me, on the whole world: God the Father.

When we know this, we can sort of relax inwardly. We are called into this same love and same outpouring of energy and self, and so our lives may be very busy and hard-working, but inwardly we can sort of collapse into God. A child throwing himself onto his Father, knowing that he will be caught and held by an assured strength, a virile tenderness, Someone he can totally trust—this is us.

So, like I say this is all very dear to my heart, and if you want to read more about my thoughts on the matter, buy my book. If you’re in the Ottawa area, come to my book launch on November 14 at 6.30 p.m. at St. Patrick’s Basilica.

But (slightly more important!) above all, come to Jesus. Go to the only one who can really show you who God the Father is. And He will—it’s what He came to do, after all. And—who knows!—we can then become precisely those sons who go out into the world to show the Father’s love to one another and to all our poor orphaned brothers and sisters who simply do not know about it.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

Assuming Our Royal Dignity

For Christians, arms extended [in the orans position] has a Christological meaning. They remind us of the extended arms of Christ on the Cross. The crucified Lord has given this primal human gesture of prayer a new depth. By extending our arms, we resolve to pray with the Crucified, to unite ourselves to his mind. In the arms of Christ, stretched on the Cross, Christians see a twofold meaning.

In his case too, in his case above all, this gesture is the radical form of worship, the unity of his human will with the will of the Father, but at the same time these arms are opened toward us—they are the wide embrace by which Christ wants to draw us to himself. Worship of God and love of neighbour—the content of the chief commandment, which sums up the law and the prophets—coincide in this gesture.
Spirit of the Liturgy, 203

Reflection – Ratzinger has been going through the various bodily postures used in prayer and exploring their deeper meaning. Here we have the orans position, the extended arms which is the normal priestly posture of prayer in the liturgy.

The word orans means ‘the praying one’ – the very image of what a person praying is. Images of an orans appear in the ancient catacombs of Rome, the very earliest examples of Christian art.

This whole business of being a praying one, a pray-er, and the attitude of mind and heart and being communicated by the gesture that accompanies it is so important. Standing up straight with arms open, arms extended—the human person fully extended in his or her physical being: this is what it means to pray.
So often we can get cramped and crimped and cropped and crouched, eh? Our humanity can feel hemmed in, constricted, limited, bent over. This happens in so many ways: material poverty, physical limitations or illness, emotional wounds and trauma, the hard knocks of a cold cruel world, the pressures and strains of doing what it takes to get by.

All of this can force us into small, tight postures and positions. All of this can impede our free and full extension of our being. Prayer, by expressing itself in the orans position, truly is the place where we reclaim our human dignity, our human fullness, our human capacity to stand up straight and open wide to God and to the world.

In the orans, we assume a posture of royal dignity, coming before God not in cringing fearful servitude but as his sons and daughters confident of our reception and of his desire that we be before him in this way. There is a whole theology and anthropology that flows from this one simple posture—the implications of it are profound.

So many people think of religion as one more thing in the world that cramps and crops and restricts humanity. There is, for sure, a discipline in our religion. The demands of the moral law and the constant challenge of prayer, fasting, and fidelity to the Church are clearly difficult. But the whole impetus of this discipline is to fashion us into the orans, the human person fully open to God and fully open to the world, standing in dignity and beauty before God and man, open to both.

This is what Ratzinger so beautifully shows in this passage. And of course his linking of it to Christ crucified is just perfect—this is the very image and the ultimate realization of human dignity and worth. The crucified Jesus is man open to God and to the world. A terrible image, but with eyes of faith we see beauty and glory there, too. And so we extend our arms in prayer, asking that the posture of our body may be reflected in the reality of our soul, and that the reality of our soul will translate into lives of worship and love, service to neighbour and deep fidelity to God. This is the point, the meaning, and the deep truth of Christian prayer, and the life it is meant to usher us into.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Worship is the Central Issue


Faced with the political and social crises of the present time and the moral challenge they offer to Christians, the problems of liturgy and prayer could easily seem to be of second importance. But the question of the moral standards and spiritual resources that we need if we are to acquit ourselves in this situation cannot be separated from the question of worship. Only if man, as man, stands before the face of God and is answerable to him, can man be secure in his dignity as a human being. Concern for the proper form of worship, therefore, is not peripheral but central to our concern for man himself.

Feast of Faith, 7

Reflection – I should perhaps state as I begin to write this that, in this early morning hour of November 7, I don’t actually know what the final results of the US election were. When I went to bed last night it was all still in play, and it is not my custom to frantically turn on media upon arising in the morning. I prefer my first hour or so of the day to be spent in prayer, reflection, and writing rather than noise and media chatter.

So I’m writing knowing full well that everyone reading this knows more about the world situation than I currently do, which is kind of funny (so… Jill Stein pulled out a surprise victory? Who knew?). (OK... I'm posting this a bit later in the day, so I know now. Oh well...)

That being said, I chose this passage from Ratzinger on purpose. It is in fact the central issue, beyond any political and social matter. Where are we before God? Where is our worship, our prayer? Are we listening to Him, and are we entrusting our lives to Him as we must? If this central relationship and central concern of life is not in order, then it doesn’t really matter who is president or prime minister or dictator-for-life in our homeland.

I love how Ratzinger links standing before the face of God and being answerable to Him with human dignity. Again, we can get so very embroiled in the immediacy of political issues and controversies—this law, that election, this scandal—and we can put all our ‘human dignity eggs’ into the rather fragile and battered basket of democratic process.

Human dignity on the deeper level flows from communion with God. While we have to strive for the most just society we can attain (which at this precise moment doesn’t seem terribly just, alas), we do need this deeper perspective. My dignity is from God and my life in and with Him. And it is my accountability to God that presses me to treat every human being as a child of God worthy of profound respect and care.

So, this ignorant blogger who doesn’t even know who won the 2012 presidential election is pondering the call we all have, which has absolutely nothing to do with who is or is not in power, with what people in high places are doing or not doing—the call to preach the Gospel with our lives and with our words. And the call to come before God and worship Him in spirit and in truth, so that He can put our lives into proper order, which is the order of charity.
 
And that’s basically all I have to say today. See you tomorrow!

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Politics and Redemption (or, Happy First Tuesday in November!)


Wherever politics tries to be redemptive, it is promising too much. When it wishes to do the work of God, it becomes, not divine, but demonic.

Truth and Tolerance, 116

Reflection – You know, I’m in a funny position today with the blog. I am Canadian, blogging from the wilderness of the Upper Ottawa Valley. However, my primary blog readership is American. Hi, y’all! And of course there is that thingamabob happening down in the USA today—something involving appointing people to a college in Ohio or whatever—I haven’t been following it too closely.

Um, yeah. And of course we Canadians are always in an odd relationship with America—a numerically tiny country rammed up against our large powerful neighbor. We tend to take an unseemly interest in your affairs, peering through the curtains of the 49th parallel, so to speak, to see what you all are up to now.

Meanwhile, I realize that Americans in general are not crazy about us furriners sticking our oar in regarding your internal affairs. If only Canadian politics were not so dreadfully dull and pointless. At least you all inject some drama and flair into your electioneering.

So anyhow, I thought I would stick my and Ratzinger’s two cents in with the above quote. I think it is wise on a day of political sweep and excitement to offer a salutary reminder of the limitations of the political sphere.

Politics and governance (which are not the same thing, precisely) are necessary, but not necessary for salvation. Politics are not redemptive. It is so crucial to get this. Four years ago so many people honestly believed Barack Obama would save America. Many others believed he would destroy America. Four years later, America is still with us, neither saved (except by the one true Savior) nor destroyed.

I honestly don’t know who’s going to win the election today. ‘Too close to call’ and ‘We’ll find out late Tuesday evening’ have been the most honest forecasts I’ve heard. But neither four more years of President Obama nor four-eight years of President Romney will save America, and probably won’t destroy it, either. America is a tough old bird of a country.

Politics is not redemptive. We do not look to the political order to usher in the kingdom of God on earth. Whenever this has been seriously tried—the Third Reich, the Soviet Union, the Khmer Rouge, the Cultural Revolution of China, the French Revolution and its Terror—the result has been to unleash hell on earth. If the political order is truly the source and driving engine of human transcendence and perfection, then it must wage war against anything opposed to its claims, which inevitably and always means killing everyone who is ‘other,’ be it the Jews, the bourgeoisie, the ancien regime, subversives.

I rather liked Clint Eastwood’s famous ‘empty chair’ speech at the Republican convention. I especially liked the part where he said that the whole political process is basically a job interview in which the employers—the voters—hire someone to do a job. If they do a decent job, we can hire them back for another go; if they do a lousy job, we get to fire them. Nice and simple, no messianic overtones, no ‘healing the planet,’ no creeping lèse majesté, no hyperbolic blather at all.

So, you Americans, this furriner ain’t going to stick his frosty Canuck nose into your affairs and tell you who to vote for. Regular readers of this blog can probably surmise my opinions of the current occupant of the Oval Office (ahem). Go and hire him back for four more years if you like the job he’s doing and fire him if you don’t.

That’s all… and oh yes, as you do that, know that America, and Canada, and Europe, and India, and the rest of the whole wide world is healed, redeemed, held, and made the seedbed of the kingdom of God not by any human power or political program, not by ideology or economy or legislation or power broking.
 
We are saved by the merciful love of God poured out in Jesus Christ, and not one thing that happens today in the USA or anywhere else in the world can hold back that merciful love from doing its work in the heart of the world and in men and women who open their hearts to receive it.

Sunday, November 4, 2012

When Know How Is Not Enough

Man knows how to do many things, and this knowledge increases all the time. If this know-how does not find its criterion in a moral norm, it becomes a power for destruction, as we can already see in the world around us.

Man knows how to clone human beings, and therefore he does so. Man knows how to use human beings as ‘storerooms’ of organs for other men, and therefore he does so. He does so, because this seems something demanded by his own liberty. Man knows how to build atomic bombs, and therefore he makes them, and he is willing in principle to use them too. Even terrorism is ultimately based on this modality of man’s ‘self-authorization’, not on the teachings of the Qur-an.

Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, 42

Reflection – This follows up admirably on yesterday’s post about human dignity. The secular rejoinder to what I said yesterday about human dignity coming from our divine origin and goal, and from our being valued and loved by God, would be to locate our human dignity in our unfettered free will, which finds its expression today in ever more powerful technological attainments.

There is a grain of truth in this, to be sure. God made us to be free, and our freedom of action is essential to this very divine origin and goal, to our ability to respond to the divine will and plan for our lives. So dignity, which derives from dignus – from what is fitting to a person, demands respect for human freedom.

But this passage from Ratzinger shows the inadequacy of this model of dignity. If we simply say that our human freedom demands we be able to do whatever we are able to do, then we are on a path to the destruction of human freedom. Absent a moral framework, absent moral laws that constrain our freedom, our freedom is negated. Some will use their freedom to perform scientific experiments on others; some will use their freedom to compel others to refrain from speech or action that is against social norms; some will use their freedom to kill and maim others in the service of political or religious ideology.

It is, perhaps, ironic that it is freedom’s limits that alone preserve freedom’s existence. But it is so. We are children living in a garden, spacious, fruitful and beautiful. But if we tear down the encircling garden wall, the sea, the wild beasts, fire and flame rush in and destroy our home.

Some atheists or secularists will hold, fiercely, to the rightness of doing so. The Nietzschean  or Sartrean philosopher will maintain that it is better to live in a wilderness and set our own terms than a beautiful garden run under someone else’s management. Better to reign in hell than serve in heaven, as Milton put it so pithily.

Ultimately the only answer to that is to maintain the goodness and love of the God who is the author of all that is. The One who made us, who made the garden (the world) and who built the wall enclosing it (the moral law) loves us and is infinitely good and wise. His plan for us is to draw us deeper and deeper into His own life and love so that the final end of man is not exactly perpetual servitude and a degrading enslavement, but the freedom of divinization.

God intends for us to become so very free in Him that we are actually sharing in His divine nature. This is always, eternally, a matter of a gift received, a grace bestowed, but no less real for that. So the current situation of a moral law that indeed curbs our ‘freedom’, is meant to preserve us in truth and in love so that our lives can mature into their full stature.

This full stature—the heavenly life—is not a matter so much of amoralism but of trans-moralism. When the fullness of the Spirit is bestowed on us, there is no more law, but not in some libertine sense of the word. Rather, when the fullness of the Spirit is bestowed on us, we will be all love, filled with divine wisdom and insight, and having no desire but to love and be loved in truth and in goodness.

This is the freedom our lives are moving towards, and we begin to know this freedom a little bit here and now as we listen to the Spirit and respond to His promptings.

Saturday, November 3, 2012

A Bold Project, An Audacious Move

We can say today with a new certitude and joyousness that the human being is indeed a divine project which only the creating Intelligence was strong and great and audacious enough to conceive of. The human being is not a mistake but something willed; he is the fruit of love. He can disclose in himself, in the bold project that he is, the language of the creating Intelligence that speaks to him and that moves him to say: Yes, Father, you have willed me.

In the Beginning, 71-2

Reflection – These words from Ratzinger, originally published decades ago, ring with ever-increasing relevance today. There are just so many attacks on human dignity, on the divine origin and goal, and the divine valuing of the human person.

Besides the obvious ones of abortion and euthanasia—the reducing of human life to something other human beings can dispose of at will—there are many faces and forms to this reduction of humanity. There is the whole hyper-sexualization of women, in particular, reducing the value of the feminine person to physical measurements and ‘hotness’. There is the reduction of the person to an economic unit of production, the virtual return of the caste system where human worth is measured by net worth. There is the ominous growth of collectivism in much of the democratic world, with its tendency to subordinate the person to society, and society to the state and the government. And then there is the terrible outright denial of human dignity that flows from radical atheism, viewing human beings as ‘meat’ living briefly in a meaningless dead universe.

All of this is all too familiar to us, so I won’t dwell on it further. Instead, this radiant picture Ratzinger presents to us is worth pondering. We have to take this personally, I think, to be able to really take hold of it. In other words, it is a good spiritual exercise to take the above passage, and every time he says ‘human being’ or some related pronoun, to replace it with ‘I’ or ‘me.

I am indeed a divine project which only the creating Intelligence was strong and great and audacious enough to conceive of. I am not a mistake but something willed; I  am the fruit of love. I can disclose in myself, in the bold project that I am, the language of the creating Intelligence that speaks to me and that moves me to say: Yes, Father, you have willed me.

Beautiful, eh? This is good self-esteem, Christian style! Personally, I like the idea of God having to be audacious to think of making Fr. Denis Lemieux, as if there was a risk that this particular one could all go terribly wrong. But this is all very beautiful—nobody is a mistake, nobody is extra, surplus, unwanted. Everyone is a bold project of God from the moment of his or her conception, with God having a special plan for how you and I are going to express, disclose the language of the creating Intelligence who made us.

We have to take this to heart, pray for the grace to really believe this about ourselves, and then be very serious about communicating this to everyone in our world. If everyone you meet today is willed by the Father and is the fruit of love, a divine project, then you will treat them with respect, right? It changes our attitude towards others, if we really believe it.

And this, to me, is the deep and consistent pro-life ethic that we simply must strive to live if the terrible assaults on human dignity are to be turned back in our times. We have to treat people like they are of divine origin and destiny; we have to, simply, love one another as Christ has loved us. The more we do this, the more all these terrible tragedies of abortion and euthanasia and exploitation and injustice simply will not happen.

So… let’s get on that today, why don’t we?

Friday, November 2, 2012

One Day I Will Wake Up

Faith in the risen Christ is nothing other than the faith of Abraham – the promise of a future and of a country… now this future is concerned in an incomparably more radical fashion. It strides across the frontier of death, which is the real antithesis to man’s attachment to the future. Man has been made so that he cannot live without a future.
Faith and the Future, 39-40

Reflection – Happy All Souls’ Day. Is that the right sentiment? It’s not exactly a ‘feast day’ – it’s one of two days in the church calendar that doesn’t fall under the usual scale of ferial-memorial-feast-solemnity (the other is Ash Wednesday). It is a day to be called to prayer for the dead, as Ash Wednesday is a day of prayer for forgiveness of sin. However, prayer is a happy act, and our faith is that God is both merciful towards sinners and desires the salvation of all, so I guess ‘Happy All Souls’ Day’ it is.

This beautiful passage from Ratzinger helps with the general happiness around this day and the subject of death in general, though, too. Man cannot live without a future—this is so true. Most of the time, most people don’t like to think about death, talk about death, contemplate their own death. There is something about the prospect of being cut off, ended, terminated, that somehow bothers most people.

Christians can be as prone to this as anyone, which is a lamentable commentary on the state of our faith. There is a normal natural anxiety around death, at least natural in our fallen condition—fear of the unknown, fear of pain, fear of an unhappy end. But Christians must, if we have faith, temper that anxiety with a lively faith in Christ.

Christ is this one striding over the frontier of death, like Moses striding across the Red Sea, like Joshua striding into the promised land. The whole Christian attitude towards death must be entirely Christ-centered, a sure and certain hope for eternal life and happiness based entirely on the resurrection of Christ.

This, I realize, is becoming increasingly incomprehensible in the secular world. We have become in our culture so earth-bound, so dreadfully confined to this life, this world, these current prospects for happiness and health and security. Even in the Church and among Christians who truly are of good will and faith, there is a curious reluctance to look upwards to the true future of mankind, the true hope in store for us.

God wants us to go to heaven, you know. We are not made to remain on this earth and in this mode of existence for a prolonged period of time. We come into being here, we are born here, and our life here and now matters tremendously… but it’s not our final destination.

And neither is the grave and the rot and corruption therein. We are made for glory, for new and lasting life in the love and light of God. The future Christ opens up for us is a beautiful joyous one. I really don’t know why our contemporary secular culture and even church culture has turned away from that with such force.

So Happy All Souls’ Day. It’s a good day to pray for all our dead, asking that God be merciful to them all and welcome them into his kingdom. And it’s a good day to have a good hard look at the reality of death—our own death, the death of everyone we know and love—and claim our deep Christian hope in the resurrection.

Catherine Doherty said about death once, “I love to talk about death, but nobody ever wants to talk about it!.. One day I will wake up and realize that I have lived in a splendor the likes of which I could never imagine. And I will understand what my heart has searched for always. I will understand love. God’s love for me, my love for God, for you, for everyone. Doesn’t that make you want to dance, want to sing, want to be happy?” Amen - that's the Christian attitude towards death.

Thursday, November 1, 2012

The Harvest Feast


The work of the theologian is secondary with regard to the real experience of the saints. Without this reference point, without the deep anchoring in such an experience, his work becomes detached from reality. This is the humility demanded of the theological… without the realism of the saints, without their contact with the reality of which theology speaks, it generates into an empty intellectual game and also loses its scientific character.

Christianity and the Crisis of Cultures, 109

Reflection -  Well, I went looking for something on the saints for today, and this is what I found. Happy All Saints Day! This truly is one of the great feasts of the Church year, ranking in the highest order of solemnity, a true completion of the Lent-Easter-Pentecost cycle. Historically it was celebrated the Sunday after Pentecost (it still is there in the Eastern calendar), and was only moved to November 1 for practical reasons. Pilgrims would come to Rome in great numbers for the feast, and the food resources of the city were inadequate to provide for the crowds.

So it got moved to November, when the harvest was in. And indeed, this is in a sense the great harvest feast of Christianity, isn’t it? The feast of the fruition of the Paschal Mystery in the life of humanity. The feast of the Holy Spirit, given in Pentecost, received in the lives of the saints. Here in the dreariest, greyest time of the year (as I write this, the remains of Sandy are soaking into the cold Canadian earth) a light shines forth, the promise of an eternal spring of new life and summer of splendor and glory. And this light is the light of Christ dwelling in and shining forth from the saints of God.

The passage from Ratzinger brings this forth quite profoundly and beautifully. Essentially, the saints are what make Christianity not an abstract idea or theory. We can talk about love, about service, about prayer, about obedience, about death to self, about God, about Jesus. We can talk and talk and talk and talk. Some of us do, quite a bit (ahem).

But if there’s no actual holiness, it’s all just talk, empty talk, pious blather, ‘an empty intellectual game.’ It is the saints who translate all this talk into a radiant reality, who verify the truth of what we say we believe.

I have had the great privilege and joy of knowing a few people I would not hesitate to call saints. I’ve blogged about them before, various members of Madonna House who have truly radiated the life of Christ for me. It’s one of the fringe benefits of hanging out in a place like MH—you get to see the reality, not just the theory of the Gospel.

But you know, I’ve also had the even greater privilege of seeing the first stirrings of sanctity, the hesitant early efforts, the hard painful slogging through the via purgativa, the touches of grace and mercy at work in the souls of many, many more people. Sanctity in its fullness is a precious and rare thing, but the beginnings of sanctity, the first flowering of the human person in the grace of God—this is not rare at all. And it is itself a beautiful thing to behold.

God is continually opening up the reality of his love and the truth of his Gospel to every one of us, to every human person. Saints may be rare birds, but saints-in-the-making are thick on the ground, and not just in a place like Madonna House. And so I would suggest that this concrete truth that Ratzinger writes about, this real experience of God that the saints have and which alone makes theology a credible exercise, while perhaps present in the saints in a pronounced and transparent fashion, is not entirely strange, not wholly unfamiliar to the rest of us.

The saints make God believable, show us that the Gospel works, to put it simply. But each of us, as we strive today to hear and respond to the voice of God and his grace, are becoming saints, too. We are showing, too, that it’s all real, it all works, and that the path of God is the path to happiness and joy and peace.
 
We may or may not be quite there yet (most of us, not), but we can still testify that we’re on the way, and that the way itself is a good thing, a beautiful thing. Something worth living for, something worth giving our life for, something worth dying for. And that’s how we become the saints of God the world so badly needs right now.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

After Twenty-Five (Billion) Years, It's Nice to Know


We live faith, not as a hypothesis, but as the certainty upon which our life is based. If two people regard their love as merely a hypothesis that is constantly in need of new verification, they destroy love in that way.

Pilgrim Fellowship of Faith, 20

Reflection – ‘Do you love me?’, Tevye asked his wife Golda in the musical Fiddler on the Roof. While the song eventually comes to a happy conclusion (‘I suppose I do!’), she initially finds it hard to answer the question. For twenty-five years they have lived together and she has done all for him that a good wife should do… but (cue the music)… ‘do you love me?’ Love, while present, proves to be an elusive, hard to verify element in their married life.

So… does God love us? Can we base our life on that love? And what does that look like? What does it mean to base our life on the certainty that God loves us? What does it mean that He loves us—what difference does it make to us?

These are deep questions, but it is the Year of Faith, and a good time to ask such deep questions. The dynamic Ratzinger describes in this short passage of the couple in love who constantly require ‘proof’ of the other’s love and so destroy the relationship is a familiar one. To have so little trust in the other person, to constantly insist on demonstrations of love, shows an insecurity that eventually erodes any hope of real communion. If we wish to be in a stable relationship with another person, we must choose to trust his or her word to us.

And so it is with God. God could say, in the theme of the song from Fiddler, that for 25 (billion) years he has given us life and provided our needs, made the sun rise, the rain fall,  and the crops grow. For 25 (billion) years He has ordered the universe in such a way that life, and then rational life, and hence all other good things (love, peace, joy, truth) are not only possible but actual realities.

But fundamentally we have to decide to trust His word to us. Do you love me? ‘I have loved you with an everlasting love.’ Do you love me? ‘The love of the Lord is eternal, abiding forever.’ Do you love me? ‘Love one another as I have loved you.’

And this faith, this choice to base our life on the certainty of God’s love, means that we accept and build our life on all the other words he has spoken—the Decalogue, the Beatitudes, the Sermon on the Mount, the Great Commandment of love of God and neighbor.

It also means believing in His steadfast presence and constant care of us, which admittedly takes a lot of believing in the tough times and hard twists and turns of life. But His word tells us He is with us always and that He is providing just what we need—certainly not what we want, but what we need right now. And so our whole attitude towards life becomes one of response, of accepting what is and meeting it with love and fidelity to God’s word.

To demand God prove His love generally means demanding God conform the universe to our desires and plans. While this is an understandable attitude (who of us has not begged God that some painful circumstance change, or that some terrible turn of events not be averted?), it is not faith. God’s love is the certain base of our life, even if everything else in our life falls apart, even if (or especially if) He seems to take away every other possible certain base for our life.
 
This is faith, and this is living by faith. And this is the constant challenge of faith before us all, and a good reflection for all of us in this Year of Faith.

Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Truth and Freedom II

[For Sartre,] man has no nature, but is sheer freedom. His life must take some direction or other, but in the end it comes to nothing. This absurd freedom is man’s hell. What is unsettling about this approach is that it is a way through the separation of freedom from truth to its most radical conclusion: there is no truth at all. Freedom has no direction and no measure.

“Truth and Freedom,” Communio 23 (Spring, 1996), 25

Reflection – Well, I seem to be having an unintentional theme this week on the blog, around the whole business of ‘truth’. It is, actually, unintentional – I have a sort of random process by which I normally select passages from Ratzinger’s writings, and these last few days the process is coughing up one truth-related quote after another.

Well, maybe it’s because so much of the media focus, at least for my largely American readership is focused so intensely on the last week of the interminable US presidential election campaign season. In a time of half-truths, no-truth, and endlessly accelerating political spin (aka BS, if you don't mind my language), it is good perhaps to ponder the utter centrality and necessity of truth and the knowledge of the truth in our lives.

So here we have a reflection on Sartre’s absurd philosophy of freedom. For Sartre, any kind of ‘reality’, any solid and unyielding fact is an outrage against freedom. Freedom is sheer unfettered action; anything that impedes our action is an assault on our liberty.

The very physical universe in its solidity is a source of nausea, and other people in their pursuit of freedom are hell for us—l’enfer-c’est les autres.

I’ve always found it hard to know what to say about Sartre’s philosophy. Little of it is argued by Sartre—he is big on the sweeping assertion and the unsubstantiated claim. His freedom seems to be a curse and his world an essentially tragic one. We are free, but there is nothing worth doing with this freedom. We are unfettered, the chains of our degrading servitude have been broken, but it turns out there is no point to life anyhow. His notion of freedom casts mankind into a prison, ironically, of utter solitude and impotent paralysis. There is literally nothing for us and nothing really worth doing in this life.

Well, if this is true, and I don’t see any great reason to think it is, then to hell with it. If that is where philosophy and careful thought about life leads us (and again, there is no reason to think they do) then to hell with them, too! And that seems to be where Sartre ended up too—I don’t think it’s any vagary of fate that he became a Stalinist Communist in his later years. If freedom leads us to such an empty tragic abyss, who needs it anyhow?

But freedom does not lead us to an empty tragic abyss, really. Freedom is essentially part of a dialogue for human beings. Reality is from God, made by God, and comes to us both externally (the created world around us) and internally (our own human being) as a given, as structured and ordered by the Other who is God. And that, basically, is what we mean by the word 'truth'.

Our freedom is our response to this given. And the response is to receive it in love and care for it in love, and to come to know that the One who gave it to us is Himself love. Freedom is our entry into this dialogue of love, this reception and return of love that is the whole purpose and joyful fulfillment of the human person. Far from l’enfer, c’est les autres, we Christians say, le paradis, c’est l’Autre. Heaven is this Other, this God, this Father who made us, who loves us, and who beckons us into a free return of love.

Like I say, I have never understood Sartre, and he always seems to me to be a tragic pitiable figure. Nietzsche, I understand and even sympathize with, but Sartre, no. So my response to him is undoubtedly inadequate, but there it is. Our Christian faith, and it seems to me that it is borne out by experience, calls us into an adventure of love and freedom that asks everything of us and promises everything to us, that plunges us into a world of risk, arduous labor, and pain, but also a life of beauty and joy beyond imagining. How Sartre’s pinched, nauseous, dark, tragic and ultimately self-defeating notions of freedom could ever be seen as better or even worth a hearing is beyond me. Meanwhile, the call of the Gospel and of love beckons me today. Goodbye, Sartre; hello, Jesus!

Monday, October 29, 2012

Truth and Freedom

The salvation offered by the Logos, by the Word of God made man, is of its nature a liberation from the slavery of appearance, a return to the truth. But the transition from appearance to the light of truth takes place in the figure of the cross.
To Look on Christ, 81

Reflection – My previous post was about truth as the necessary ground for communion. Without a shared reality, without at least some shared meaning, no communication, and hence no community is possible.
This passage takes up the theme of truth and develops it further. Jesus tells us that the truth will set us free (John 8:32). Truth is liberation – to live in reality is to live in freedom from illusion and artifice. But this truth comes to us, Ratzinger tells us, in the figure of the cross.

Now what does that mean? I don’t have the original passage in context in front of me, but I see two interwoven meanings here. First, when we come into the truth, we see things as they are, as opposed to what we would like them to be. Reality is what it is; our desires are not king of the world. The entire cosmos, in a sense, is like Rhett to our Scarlett saying to us, ‘Frankly, my dear, I don’t give a damn (what you want).’

So of course, to live in truth is to live in humility, and of course this hurts our ego. We must accept that we are just one little person in a very big world, and that our primary call is to accept things as they are, since all our efforts and energies can only make a small difference in the world.

So this hurts, and so truth comes to us in the figure of the cross. But there is a deeper meaning to all this, of course. The cross is not merely a symbol of pain and helplessness, right? Jesus died on the cross, and the cross then becomes not only the symbol but the deep realization of the deepest truth of all.

And this truth is the infinite love and mercy of God poured out, freely given, big enough for every human being to have a full share in it. This is the deepest truth of reality, of the cosmos and what lies beneath and above it. Reality comes to us hard and unyielding, like the wood of the cross, yet it is by lying on that cross that we come to know we are sharing it with our Lord who loves us.

‘The cross is the marriage bed of Christ and humanity.’ To accept the sorrowful mystery of things as they are, and to discover within them the mysterious awesome presence, power, and love of God—this is the truth that liberates us. We have nothing to fear. There is no reality we need to flee from or deny or reject. Even the most horrific and agonizing turns of fate can be and indeed are met by the mercy and love of God coming out to us from the very heart of the world’s anguish.

This is our Christian faith, and from this faith comes the power to love and spend ourselves freely for the life of the world. And that is what we mean by freedom in our religion.

Saturday, October 27, 2012

Truth and Community


To the extent that men allow themselves to be guided and cleansed by the truth, they find the way not only to their true selves, but also to the human ‘thou’. Truth, in fact, is the medium where men make contact, whereas it is the absence of truth which closes them off from one another.

The Nature and Mission of Theology, 39

Reflection – I’m in Toronto this week, which I don’t think I’ve mentioned on this blog yet. We have a Madonna House here in the big city, in the west end on Parkside Drive, and I’m giving a retreat and offering my priestly services to the seven valiant souls preaching the Gospel with their lives here in Canada’s biggest city.

So, being in Toronto this week I’m much aware of the five million human ‘thous’ surrounding me on all sides for miles around. It’s… very different from Combermere! And the challenges of peaceful co-existence in a big city are very real. Ratzinger’s reflections about this are penetrating and profound, worth a careful reading and reflection.

The general tendency of modernity is to say that, for purposes of peaceful co-existence, we have to set aside questions of truth. After all, in a big city like Toronto, people of all religions and no religion are all jostling up together in the subways and on the sidewalk. Surely we must adopt a sort of ‘practical relativism’ at least, just to be able to live together. It’s common sense, right?

Ratzinger challenges this ‘common sense’ approach. He observes that unless there is some common ground, some shared medium of reality, no communication is even possible at all. There has to be some shared truth for two people to even exchange a greeting or meet on the same field of reality. Suppose I say ‘hello’ to you, but for you ‘hello’ means something grievously insulting. You haul off and punch me in the face, and I say something appropriate to that situation (and inappropriate for a G-rated blog!), but that pithy sentiment to you means ‘thank you! Do that again!’ Well… what we have here is a failure to communicate, as the old movie line said.

This is pure logic, that any communication requires a commonality of meaning, of truth. But we have to take this logic and run with it as far as we can. Because what is shown here is that it is not truth which divides and isolates, but a lack of truth. If we simple leave things at the level of ‘you think what you think, and I think what I think, and that’s the end of the matter,’ then it truly is the end of the matter. It is certainly the end of the conversation. If the matter is important enough, it may be the end of the relationship. When there is no way of seeking the truth together, when there is no chance of at least coming together in a mutual desire to know the truth, we are deeply isolated.

De gustibus non disputandem—there is no discussion in matters of taste. I like hot foods and you like sweet and there is no right or wrong, truth or falsehood in that. But in our post-modern world, all statements are reduced to matters of taste. I like the taste of Catholicism and you like the taste of radical atheism… and so there is nothing to discuss.

Taste is about what we want. When all truth claims are reduced to this, then it becomes a matter of appetite and desire and wanting to believe what we want to believe. It all gets very dark and sub-rational and somehow less than human. And in this, communication fails; community fails.
Truth, then, stands as the great safeguard and guarantor of human community and communication.

Unless we have a commitment to seek the truth and accept its demands, unless we accept a certain asceticism of the truth, we cannot be together with one another. Ultimately, we are just concerned with our own wants, likes, dislikes, and everything and everyone else is subordinated to those. Truth, and the humility and discipline it demands of us, is the precondition of genuine love and communion.

Friday, October 26, 2012

A Spittle-Flecked Rant?

The common practice today is to measure the Bible against the so-called modern worldview, whose fundamental dogma is that God cannot act in history—that everything to do with God is to be relegated to the domain of subjectivity. And so the Bible no longer speaks of God, the living God; no, now we alone speak and decide what God can do and what we will and should do… any exegesis that reads the Bible from the perspective of faith in the living God, in order to listen to what God has to say, is fundamentalism; … only the supposedly purely scientific kind of exegesis, in which God says nothing and has nothing to say, is able to keep abreast of the times.

Jesus of Nazareth 1, 35-6

Reflection – You know, at the risk of sounding a bit self-centred, sometimes I wonder if I haven’t actually started this blog as a sort of spiritual exercise in self-control. I seem to delight in challenging myself to write about subjects that I feel extremely passionate about, things that get my emotions all fired up and ready to go… and then try to write about them with some degree of calmness, not devolving into a spittle-flecked wild-eyed rant, a screed which would send my readers running to the hills and (probably) send my superior in MH to tap me on the shoulder and suggest I take up some other hobby that will be not quite so hard on the blood pressure. Knitting, perhaps.

Like yesterday’s post on the liturgy, and today’s post on the Bible, and our modern disease of somehow relegating God to some strange place in both those forums, a place of inactivity or at least no direct activity or presence. A weird (frankly) approach to both liturgy and the Word where it is human action and human thought that bear the meaning and value of the thing, not the real presence of the living God.

I am passionate about these matters. God is real, and the real God is really acting in our lives. If this was not true, I at any rate would be dead, I think. When the real Lord really found me and really spoke to me a word of love and life, all of which really happened when I was 16 years old, I was at that time a pretty miserable wretched specimen of a human being. I don’t honestly think I would have made it very far into adulthood, to be perfectly honest.

God saved me. God saves so many people, and I firmly and deeply believe His whole desire and constant action in time and history is to save every person. And this salvation came to me (really) in the Eucharistic presence of Christ and has been repeatedly and profoundly confirmed and deepened by his living Word where he really has spoken and acted in my life.

So, yes, I get a little passionate about these things. This strange modern attitude which always keeps God at one remove (at least) from human affairs and human history is utterly incomprehensible to me. It is bloodless, lifeless, pointless. When liturgy becomes all about me or all about us, when the Scriptures become mere human documents that can be pulled and twisted to mean ‘whatever’ because there is no actual inherent meaning, then we lose the living God in a cloud of obfuscation and vagueness, entomb him again behind the stones of subjectivity and egoism.

Well, He cannot be entombed, and does not stay so. And that’s the Good News, of course. God breaks through our nonsense—‘creative’ liturgies and bloodless scientific exegesis, and continues to reach down from heaven to earth to save the poor and lowly ones who cry out to Him. It happened to me; it can happen to you or to anyone. God is real.

So there—how did I do today? Anyone flecked with spittle yet? OK - end of rant. See you tomorrow!

Thursday, October 25, 2012

The End of Creativity

‘Creativity’ cannot be an authentic category for matters liturgical… creativity means that in a universe that in itself is meaningless and came into existence through blind evolution, man can creatively fashion a new and better world.

Modern theories of art think in terms of a nihilistic kind of creativity. Art is not meant to copy anything. Artistic creativity is under the free mastery of man, without being bound by norms of goals and subject to no questions of meaning. It may be that in such visions a cry for freedom is to be heard, a cry that in a world totally in the control of technology becomes a cry for help. Seen in this way, art appears as the final refuge of freedom.

True, art has something to do with freedom, but freedom understood in the way we have been describing is empty. It is not redemptive, but makes despair sound like the last word of human existence. This kind of creativity has no place within the liturgy.
Spirit of the Liturgy, 168

Reflection – Ratzinger speaks strongly here, and of course his words have to be understood properly. In a very different context he speaks positively of creativity, saying that “We can only be really creative if we are in harmony with the Creator of the universe. We can only really serve the earth if we accept it under the aegis of God’s word. Then we shall be able to further and fulfill both ourselves and the world.” (In the Beginning, 52).

We are all, however, all too familiar with ‘creativity’ within liturgy, when a certain attitude emerges that practically the one thing we cannot do in the liturgy is what the book tells us to do—any other words, gestures, arrangements will do except the ones given by the Church. It is this which Ratzinger criticizes, along with an idea that what is truly valuable in liturgy is what we creatively contribute, not what is already there, given.

This idea—that the ‘given’, the ‘already there’ is of little value until we gussy it up a bit—is troubling outside of liturgy, but is blasphemous within it. What is given in liturgy? The Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ, right? Whatever human contribution we make to this Supreme Given is of relatively little importance, right?

Ratzinger goes on to discuss modern theories of art. I have to confess (non-artist that I am) that I simply have to take his word on these matters theoretical. But if these theories are indeed dominant in the art world, then there truly can be no place for them in liturgy. Liturgy is the place of supreme meaning, absolute truth, the perfect form of God coming down to form us according to the pattern of his divinity. Art as rebellion, as a protest against form or meaning or truth, cannot be expressed in this wholly divine way.

I guess as a priest and not an artist I tend to look at myself here, though. We priests have to be very careful in our ‘creative’ license, liturgically. I am glad that with the new translation of the Mass has come a renewed emphasis on simply saying the words that are written down in the book. No paraphrasing, no creative editing, no ‘in these or similar words’ any more. Just say the black, do the red. Hurray!

But even then, even with a total fidelity to the rubrics and texts, we priests have to be very careful. It’s a matter of the heart, a sense that it is on us, somehow, to make this Mass ‘meaningful’, that our (brilliant, of course!) homily or our inflections or our dramatic flourishes are somehow really really really important if the Mass is going to have an impact on people.

Ugh. The Mass is meaningful because it is Full of Meaning, and that Meaning is the living presence of Christ. It has an impact because the full power of the living God is there, not because Fr. Lemieux is so wonderful (snort!), but because Jesus is.

We have to go deep into these things, all of us. Because Fr. X or Fr. Y or this or that liturgical expression or way of singing or habit—all of this is passing away. We have to abandon our false creativity and plunge deeply into the Creator of all who is there at the heart of the Mass and at the heart of each of our lives, awaiting us. He will show us how to be creative according to his truth and his love.

Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Breaking Up Tiles


Evidently, knowledge of the content of faith is essential for giving one’s own assent, that is to say for adhering fully with intellect and will to what the Church proposes. Knowledge of faith opens a door into the fullness of the saving mystery revealed by God. The giving of assent implies that, when we believe, we freely accept the whole mystery of faith, because the guarantor of its truth is God who reveals himself and allows us to know his mystery of love.

On the other hand, we must not forget that in our cultural context, very many people, while not claiming to have the gift of faith, are nevertheless sincerely searching for the ultimate meaning and definitive truth of their lives and of the world. This search is an authentic “preamble” to the faith, because it guides people onto the path that leads to the mystery of God. Human reason, in fact, bears within itself a demand for “what is perennially valid and lasting”. This demand constitutes a permanent summons, indelibly written into the human heart, to set out to find the One whom we would not be seeking had he not already set out to meet us. To this encounter, faith invites us and it opens us in fullness.

Porta Fidei 10

Reflection – This passage is among the most beautiful in this apostolic letter. The Pope first links the whole business of the content of the faith—the creed, the dogmas, the Scriputures—to the underlying deeper dynamic of faith. We hand over our lives, accept the Lordship of Christ and the gift of God’s life for us, in a way that is essentially and inextricably united with the assent of the intellect to revealed truth.

In our post-modern world there is a great movement, a sort of centrifugal force towards the separation of things, the fragmenting of reality. Everything is broken up into little bits and we all go foraging to pick up the little bits that suit us. It’s like mosaic work, where ceramic tiles are broken up into tiny pieces that the artist assembles into the picture he or she desires. All of reality is broken up tile, and every one of us is making up our own picture from the fragments.

This fragmented approach to life is simply not the Catholic vision. Our whole Catholic tradition is that reality is a whole, an integrated piece, a seamless garment. Not a mosaic made up of fragments, but an icon written by a sure strong hand. Do not forget that the very word Catholic is from the Greek kata holos—roughly, ‘corresponding to the whole’. Universal, all-encompassing, complete, in other words.

So we cannot, must not, make blanket statements of separation and fragmentation. Well, I believe in Jesus, but the Church I’m not so sure of… well, I like the Gospels, but all these dogmas drive me crazy… well, I like the New Testament, but the Old is so harsh… well, I like the theology of the first millennium, but things went a little crazy after that…

Breaking up the tiles! Making a mosaic! Creating a little picture of Catholicism that corresponds, not to the whole of it, but to the little bits that I like. Essentially, making Catholicism over again in my image, according to my likeness.

We have to be very careful about that, as it is the spirit of the age, and all of us are subject to it to some degree. We do live in a broken, fragmented world, but our Catholic faith is that God has communicated to us the unbroken image, a restored vision of reality and truth that comes to us through the ministry of the Church, itself made up of broken flawed individuals.

Of course, in this it is so beautiful and compassionate that the Pope offers such deep respect and concern for the many people who search and struggle and cannot find their way to the Catholic faith but who nonetheless earnestly desire the truth. This is a holy struggle and a blessed search, and the whole pastoral energy of the Church—of all of us—must be towards putting forth the Catholic vision of life with greater and deeper clarity so that all these good, hungry people might find their way to it more easily.
 
And so this one paragraph, Porta Fidei 10, which I’ve blogged on these last days is a truly marvellous thing—a whole vision of faith in the heart which is expressed on the lips and yields an all-embracing integrated vision of reality. There is enough in this one paragraph to give us food for thought, prayer, and action for this year of faith.

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Leaving the Cupboard

Confessing with the lips indicates in turn that faith implies public testimony and commitment. A Christian may never think of belief as a private act. Faith is choosing to stand with the Lord so as to live with him. This “standing with him” points towards an understanding of the reasons for believing. Faith, precisely because it is a free act, also demands social responsibility for what one believes. The Church on the day of Pentecost demonstrates with utter clarity this public dimension of believing and proclaiming one’s faith fearlessly to every person. It is the gift of the Holy Spirit that makes us fit for mission and strengthens our witness, making it frank and courageous.

Profession of faith is an act both personal and communitarian. It is the Church that is the primary subject of faith. In the faith of the Christian community, each individual receives baptism, an effective sign of entry into the people of believers in order to obtain salvation. As we read in the Catechism of the Catholic Church: “ ‘I believe’ is the faith of the Church professed personally by each believer, principally during baptism. ‘We believe’ is the faith of the Church confessed by the bishops assembled in council or more generally by the liturgical assembly of believers. ‘I believe’ is also the Church, our mother, responding to God by faith as she teaches us to say both ‘I believe’ and ‘we believe’.”
Porta Fidei 10

Reflection  - There is much to muse on in this passage, much food for thought. There are always two extremes which distort the nature of faith. There is the social/communitarian model of faith, whereby faith is just ‘what everyone does.’ We’re all Catholics, so let’s all go to Mass now—that kind of thing. While this was more common reality in previous eras, people who grow up in strong religious families can still fall into this extreme. We’re Catholics, Catholics have certain rules that they live by, and here’s what they are, so shape up, buddy!

Of course what is missing here is any sense of a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, with God as Father, with the Holy Spirit as a real active presence. But then this personal model of faith can also become distorted. Me and Jesus and that’s all there is to it, a wholly individualistic and private matter of the heart. Very little if any sense of a community, a responsibility to be part of a group, a body, a society with moral obligations. Just… me and Jesus! All very cozy, but not really right.

Because Jesus didn’t live that way, you know. And ‘faith is choosing to stand with the Lord so as to live with Him.’ Jesus’ own relationship with the Father clearly had and has a personal intimacy and a directness that beggars our imagination – we’re talking about the relations of the Trinity here, about which we know precisely nothing! But the way Jesus lived out this intimate unity with His Father plunged Him fully into the life of the community, of the society of his time and people.

His engagements with the Pharisees, His teachings about the law and its application, His own practice of the Jewish liturgical life, His profound development for his disciples of the moral demands, the social principles, the all-encompassing implications of his Gospel—all of this makes nonsense of any kind of individualistic ‘me and Jesus’ faith.

Catherine Doherty used to tell a favourite story of her patron saint Catherine of Siena. St. Catherine began her life with God living a solitary life of prayer and penance in a cupboard under the stairs of her family home. This went well for quite a while, and she had mystical graces and all that good stuff. But one day Jesus said to her, “Now I want you to go out and serve my people.” She objected that she wanted to stay there and just be with Him. He said, “Well, you can stay in the cupboard, but I won’t be here!” And St. Catherine promptly went running out of the cupboard and dedicated the rest of her life to passionate, heroic service of the sick, the poor, and the troubled Church of her day.

Jesus calls all of us—even those genuinely called to be solitary hermits—out of the cupboard. Faith begins in ‘the cupboard’—that beautiful intimacy with Christ in the depths of our hearts—but once Christ is there, the cupboard door flies open, and we are called to live and love and serve and ultimately die for the world. Because that’s what Jesus did, and faith is all about standing with Him and living His life.

Monday, October 22, 2012

The Place of Yes and No


At this point I would like to sketch a path intended to help us understand more profoundly not only the content of the faith, but also the act by which we choose to entrust ourselves fully to God, in complete freedom. In fact, there exists a profound unity between the act by which we believe and the content to which we give our assent. Saint Paul helps us to enter into this reality when he writes: “Man believes with his heart and so is justified, and he confesses with his lips and so is saved” (Rom 10:10). The heart indicates that the first act by which one comes to faith is God’s gift and the action of grace which acts and transforms the person deep within.

The example of Lydia is particularly eloquent in this regard. Saint Luke recounts that, while he was at Philippi, Paul went on the Sabbath to proclaim the Gospel to some women; among them was Lydia and “the Lord opened her heart to give heed to what was said by Paul” (Acts 16:14). There is an important meaning contained within this expression. Saint Luke teaches that knowing the content to be believed is not sufficient unless the heart, the authentic sacred space within the person, is opened by grace that allows the eyes to see below the surface and to understand that what has been proclaimed is the word of God.

Porta Fidei 10

Reflection – OK, time for another little series on the blog. One unfortunate result of the last two weeks when missions and operations (which all sounds very military and special forces…) have reduced my blogging capacity severely is that I more or less have missed this whole first couple of weeks of the Year of Faith. So let’s spend a few days on our ongoing journey through Porta Fidei, why don’t we?

Pope Benedict in this key passage from paragraph 10 of the letter alludes to an old and key distinction in the term ‘faith’. In technical language, there is the fides quae, which is the actual doctrines, creeds, propositions that make up our Catholic faith: God is three persons in the one divine nature; Christ is true God and true man; the Eucharist is the Body and Blood of Christ. But then there is the fides qua, the very act of believing, what we are doing when we give our assent to these truths, and what it means for our lives.

As the Pope points out so rightly, though, these two ‘faiths’ are intimately united. It is part of our content of faith, the ‘quae’, that faith is a response to grace, a gift of God in its first movement to which our freedom gives its assent. God is the initiator, the first mover in our life of faith, and this is so crucial.

The Lord opened Lydia’s heart to receive the words Paul preached. This is the first movement and the most essential in the life of faith. And yet what a mystery this is! Don’t you find it so? Why do I have faith (presuming, Lord have mercy on me, that I do!) while others who seem just as good if not much better than me do not? What is this strange gift of God that in our Christian understanding is necessary for salvation, and yet seems to be given to some and not to others.

And yet… God must offer this gift to everyone, surely? It really is very mysterious, and I suppose ultimately we are not going to understand God’s ways on this matter until we are on the other side. As Aslan said to Lucy in Voyage of the Dawn Treader, no one is ever told any story except his own. I know that God has come to me and opened my heart to accept the Gospel as His own truth; I know He did this because He loves me very much indeed; I have to assume this same love and mercy are at work in every human heart, and that the fullness of time will show this to be the case.

It’s this whole business of the heart, that secret silent sanctuary buried deep in each human person. That’s where the action is going on, the strange mysterious encounter of each man and woman with God, the place of ‘Yes’ and ‘No’, a dialogue no other human being is privy to and a wrestling match that occurs strictly under cover of darkness and alone (cf. Gen 32).
 
That is where faith starts, but it’s not where faith ends. And that’s what the Pope will go on to discuss… tomorrow. See you then.